What we got right. What we got wrong. What we're still watching.
Every clear investment view published by MoatPeak stays on this page. We record what we expected, when we published it and what happened next. Successful views remain visible. Unsuccessful views remain visible too.
Right
The call's own test was met, or the price reached our fair value.
Wrong
The stated trigger fired, the window closed without the test being met, or the price moved beyond our own range.
Hit rate
Right as a share of the 92 calls that have been decided.
Still open
14 leaning right, 30 leaning wrong, 90 too early to judge.
36 more views are listed but not scored: Hold and watchlist views, and calls without a test. Counts are worked out from the register below. Results describe whether the original research argument was supported by the evidence. They do not represent portfolio returns or personalised investment recommendations.
Every call, by section
A row is added when the research is published. Results are graded on 3 Nov 2026 closing prices and reviewed every month. Closed results are not reopened, in either direction.
| Section | Right | Wrong | Hit rate | Leaning right | Leaning wrong | Too early | Not scored |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Daily Compass tests | 49 | 24 | 67% | 0 | 0 | 71 | 8 |
| Company calls | 3 | 6 | 33% | 4 | 9 | 8 | 16 |
| Macro and theme calls | 1 | 5 | 17% | 10 | 20 | 11 | 11 |
| Calls in Learn articles | 2 | 2 | 50% | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| All sections | 55 | 37 | 60% | 14 | 30 | 90 | 36 |
Dated tests published in the Daily Compass. Most are written against us: they say what would prove our reading wrong. From 9 June to 11 August we kept a daily scorecard: 38 right, 3 wrong. From 12 August every test is listed here one by one.
| ID | Opened | Test | Booked | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DC-T-111 | 3 Nov 2026 | Anthropic's listing prices at a valuation of 1.5 trillion dollars or more, on Bloomberg's or Reuters' report, before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Opened in the 3 November Daily Compass. | |
| DC-T-110 | 3 Nov 2026 | Oracle announces no new bond or share sale of 1 billion dollars or more, except pure refinancing, from 4 November 2026 to 31 May 2027If met, it counts against us | Open Opened in the 3 November Daily Compass. | |
| DC-T-042 | 2 Nov 2026 | The Magnificent Seven fund MAGS beats the bond fund LQD from their 30 October closes to 31 December 2026, on Yahoo Finance's closesIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-041 | 2 Nov 2026 | Leases signed but not yet started at Alphabet, Meta, Microsoft and Amazon total less than 1,108.3 billion dollars at 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-044 | 31 Oct 2026 | The PHLX semiconductor index beats the S&P 500 from their 30 October closes to 31 December 2026, on Yahoo Finance's closesIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-043 | 31 Oct 2026 | Amazon's advertising sales for the fourth quarter of 2026 are 24.5 billion dollars or more, in its fourth quarter reportIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-046 | 30 Oct 2026 | A US AI linked high yield bond of 1 billion dollars or more prices before 30 November 2026, on Bloomberg's or Goldman's reportIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-045 | 30 Oct 2026 | Amazon's free cash flow for the fourth quarter of 2026 is positive, on operating cash flow less net equipment spendingIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-048 | 29 Oct 2026 | Alphabet's net proceeds from new common stock in the fourth quarter of 2026 are below 12 billion dollarsIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-047 | 29 Oct 2026 | Alphabet's Class A shares beat Microsoft's from their 29 October closes to 31 December 2026, on Yahoo Finance's closesIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-050 | 28 Oct 2026 | Moody's count of US life insurers' AI linked holdings at end December 2026, published before 30 June 2027, is below 100 billion dollarsIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-049 | 28 Oct 2026 | No new Broadcom loan, guarantee or backstop of 10 billion dollars or more for a customer is agreed before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-052 | 27 Oct 2026 | Neither Microsoft nor Amazon announces a sale of new shares worth 5 billion dollars or more before 31 March 2027If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-051 | 27 Oct 2026 | Meta's shares beat the S&P 500 from their 27 October close to 31 December 2026, on Yahoo Finance's closesIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-054 | 26 Oct 2026 | The S&P 500 closes 5 percent below its 23 October close before 31 December 2026 without a VIX close above 25 firstIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-053 | 26 Oct 2026 | The investment grade default swap index closes above its March high of 68 basis points before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-056 | 24 Oct 2026 | Michigan's one year inflation expectation reads 4.5 percent or less in its final November 2026 surveyIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-055 | 24 Oct 2026 | OpenAI raises 25 billion dollars or more at a valuation of 1.25 trillion or more by 30 November 2026, on the FT's or Bloomberg's reportIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-058 | 23 Oct 2026 | The ten year falls on each of the next three days the S&P 500 drops 1 percent or more with Brent above 100 dollars, by 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-057 | 23 Oct 2026 | Meta's next bond deal before 31 December 2026 draws peak orders of four times its size or 125 billion dollars, on Bloomberg's reportIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-060 | 22 Oct 2026 | Indirect bidders take 65 percent or more of the November thirty year auction, by 30 November 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-059 | 22 Oct 2026 | By 28 February 2027, the midpoints of Meta's first 2027 ranges put total expenses plus capital spending at 435 billion dollars or lessIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-062 | 21 Oct 2026 | Meta's five year default swaps are reported below 80 basis points by the FT, Bloomberg or S&P Global before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-061 | 21 Oct 2026 | The S&P 500 closes above its 6 October record of 7,818.93 on any day before 30 November 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-064 | 20 Oct 2026 | FRED's CCC and lower spread closes below 11 percentage points on any day before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-063 | 20 Oct 2026 | CoreWeave raises new debt, secured or unsecured, at an all in cost of 10.5 percent or less before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-066 | 19 Oct 2026 | Front month Brent settles below 100 dollars on any day before 30 November 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-065 | 19 Oct 2026 | DayOne's US listing prices within or above the first range it files, before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-068 | 17 Oct 2026 | Morgan Stanley's or BofA's dated count shows 55 percent or more of S&P 500 members above their 200 day average before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | 3 Nov 2026 | Wrong Fired against us on 2 November: Morgan Stanley's Mike Wilson counts 62 percent of S&P 500 members above their 200 day average, up about 20 points since the end of September, in a note MarketWatch reported that day. |
| DC-T-067 | 17 Oct 2026 | Goldman's US AI linked high yield spread is reported below 300 basis points before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-070 | 16 Oct 2026 | Goldman's prime book shows global AI stocks back above 30 percent of hedge funds' single stock net exposure before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-069 | 16 Oct 2026 | Oracle's five year swaps close below 250 basis points, on Bloomberg's, Deutsche Bank's or Goldman's figures, before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-072 | 15 Oct 2026 | Anthropic's listing prices at a valuation of 1.8 trillion dollars or more, on Bloomberg or Reuters, before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-071 | 15 Oct 2026 | CoreWeave's five year default swaps close below 800 basis points, on Dow Jones Market Data or Bloomberg, before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-074 | 14 Oct 2026 | JPMorgan buys back 5 billion dollars or more of its own shares in the fourth quarter of 2026, as reported in its January 2027 resultsIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-073 | 14 Oct 2026 | The next unguaranteed chip loan above 3 billion dollars to a compute provider is fully underwritten before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-076 | 13 Oct 2026 | US bankruptcy filings for October 2026 are below October 2025's on the American Bankruptcy Institute's count, by 30 November 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-075 | 13 Oct 2026 | Broadcom's five year default swaps close below 100 basis points on Goldman's or LSEG's figures before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-077 | 12 Oct 2026 | The US average retail diesel price, on the EIA's weekly figure, falls below 5 dollars a gallon before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-028 | 12 Oct 2026 | The S&P 500 closes above 8,000 on any day before 31 October 2026 with the ten year at or above 5 percent | 31 Oct 2026 | Written against us. The S&P 500 never closed above 8,000; its record close was 7,818.93 on 6 October. |
| DC-T-078 | 9 Oct 2026 | OpenAI's annualised revenue is reported at 70 billion dollars or more on the same measure as the 50 billion, before 31 March 2027If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-016 | 9 Oct 2026 | The thirty year Treasury yield closes below 5.40 percent on any day before 31 October 2026 | 23 Oct 2026 | Wrong The thirty year closed at 5.29 percent on 22 October on the Treasury's daily curve, below our 5.40 line. |
| DC-T-079 | 8 Oct 2026 | The MBA average thirty year fixed mortgage rate falls below 7 percent before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-013 | 8 Oct 2026 | Indirect bidders take 65 percent or more at the next three nominal coupon auctions, from the 8 October thirty year, by 30 November 2026 | 22 Oct 2026 | Indirect bidders took 58.2 percent of the twenty year sale on 21 October, below the 65 percent line, so three in a row could no longer happen. |
| DC-T-081 | 7 Oct 2026 | The French ten year spread to Germany closes below 100 basis points before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-080 | 7 Oct 2026 | The equal weighted S&P 500 closes at a 52 week high before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-030 | 6 Oct 2026 | A published flow figure or Aramco statement dated after 5 October puts the Saudi pipeline above half capacity, by 31 October 2026 | 2 Nov 2026 | Wrong Saudi Arabia's energy minister said on 6 October that the line was back at 5.8 million barrels a day, above half capacity. We missed it for four weeks. |
| DC-T-011 | 6 Oct 2026 | This week's ten and thirty year Treasury auctions both clear without a tail, by 8 October 2026 | 9 Oct 2026 | Wrong Both sold without a tail: the ten year 1.7 basis points through and the thirty year 0.1 through. |
| DC-T-082 | 5 Oct 2026 | Goldman's US fundamental hedge fund net leverage tops 55 percent with the S&P 500 within 3 percent of its high by 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-015 | 5 Oct 2026 | The 10 year Treasury yield closes below 5 percent on a day Brent settles above 100 dollars, before 31 December 2026 | 23 Oct 2026 | Wrong On 22 October the ten year closed at 4.955 percent while December Brent settled at 113.17 dollars, so high oil did not hold yields up. |
| DC-T-083 | 3 Oct 2026 | The ICE BofA US high yield option adjusted spread closes above 400 basis points on any day before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-014 | 3 Oct 2026 | The 10 year Treasury yield closes below 5 percent on any day before 31 October 2026 | 23 Oct 2026 | Wrong The ten year closed at 4.955 percent on 22 October, on Investing.com's data. |
| DC-T-085 | 25 Sep 2026 | Oracle withdraws the Project Jupiter force majeure notice before 31 March 2027If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-084 | 25 Sep 2026 | A second anchor tenant of a data centre above 1 gigawatt issues a force majeure notice before 31 March 2027If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-087 | 24 Sep 2026 | The 10 year Treasury yield closes below 4.75 percent on any day before 31 December 2026If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-086 | 24 Sep 2026 | A Treasury coupon auction tails by more than 2 basis points again before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-089 | 23 Sep 2026 | A chip vendor discloses a residual value guarantee liability above 150 billion dollars in a quarterly filing before 31 March 2027If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-088 | 23 Sep 2026 | A large artificial intelligence data centre listing is completed at or above its asked valuation before 31 March 2027If met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-091 | 22 Sep 2026 | A specialist compute provider raises new debt at an all in cost above 11 percent before 31 March 2027If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-090 | 22 Sep 2026 | The share of S&P 500 members more than 20 percent below their own highs falls below 45 percent before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-093 | 21 Sep 2026 | A data centre project of more than 1 gigawatt is publicly cancelled or indefinitely suspended before 31 March 2027If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-092 | 21 Sep 2026 | The Project Jupiter loans trade below 85 cents on the dollar before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-094 | 18 Sep 2026 | The American average retail petrol price reaches 5 dollars a gallon before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-010 | 18 Sep 2026 | The 10 year Treasury yield reaches 5.25 percent before 31 December 2026 | 3 Oct 2026 | The ten year closed at 5.292 percent on 30 September, on Dow Jones Market Data. On 25 September we had fixed the reading as a close, which made it harder for us to win. |
| DC-T-095 | 17 Sep 2026 | The December 2026 projections show at least one cut for 2027If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-024 | 17 Sep 2026 | The S&P 500 closes below 7,550 before 31 October 2026 | 31 Oct 2026 | Wrong The S&P 500 traded as low as 7,527.56 but closed at 7,580.07 on 30 October, and our rule reads a close. |
| DC-T-097 | 16 Sep 2026 | American diesel inventories are reported back within 5 percent of the five year average before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-096 | 16 Sep 2026 | The S&P 500 forward price to earnings ratio falls below 18 times before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-029 | 15 Sep 2026 | The Saudi East to West pipeline is still not fully restarted on 31 October 2026 | 2 Nov 2026 | Wrong The line was running at 5.8 million barrels a day on 6 October, Saudi Arabia's energy minister said, with capacity of about 7 million. |
| DC-T-012 | 15 Sep 2026 | The software index beats the semiconductor index again over the month to 15 October 2026 | 20 Oct 2026 | Wrong On Yahoo Finance's closes the software fund IGV rose 3.8 percent from 15 September to 15 October, against 3.2 percent for the chip fund SOXX. |
| DC-T-098 | 14 Sep 2026 | The Federal Reserve raises again in October or December, making September the start of a seriesIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-009 | 14 Sep 2026 | The 10 year Japanese government bond yield reaches or exceeds 3 percent before 31 October 2026 | 22 Sep 2026 | The Japanese ten year passed 3.0 percent, on Bloomberg data as of 15 September, the first time in three decades. We booked it a week late. |
| DC-T-099 | 11 Sep 2026 | The Treasury cuts long dated auction sizes or retires the twenty year bond by 30 November 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-023 | 11 Sep 2026 | The S&P 500 closes 2 percent or more below its 10 September close before 31 October 2026 | 31 Oct 2026 | Wrong The S&P 500 never closed 2 percent below its 10 September close of 7,591.70; it ended the period at 7,580.07. |
| DC-T-033 | 10 Sep 2026 | Hyperscaler and chip related debt issuance for 2027 is reported above 340 billion dollars by 31 March 2027 | Closed, not scored Retired unscored on 17 October as badly worded: a 2027 total cannot be reported by 31 March 2027. | |
| DC-T-027 | 10 Sep 2026 | The 10 year Treasury yield closes above 4.837 percent on 31 October 2026 | 31 Oct 2026 | The ten year closed at 4.929 percent on 30 October, on Investing.com's data, above the 4.837 line. |
| DC-T-101 | 9 Sep 2026 | The 30 year Treasury yield closes above 5.2 percent on 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-100 | 9 Sep 2026 | The VIX closes above 25 on any day before 31 December 2026If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-022 | 9 Sep 2026 | The dollar trades below 150 yen on any day before 31 October 2026 | 31 Oct 2026 | Wrong The dollar closed at 157.80 yen on 30 October and traded no lower than 156.97, on Yahoo Finance's data. |
| DC-T-026 | 8 Sep 2026 | The six month Brent contract trades above 90 dollars on 31 October 2026 | 31 Oct 2026 | Every Brent contract to October 2027 settled above 90 dollars on 30 October, on ICE data via Barchart. |
| DC-T-020 | 8 Sep 2026 | December European gas closes above 100 euros a megawatt hour on any day before 30 November 2026 | 30 Oct 2026 | The December contract settled at 100.341 euros on 28 October on ICE Endex, on Barchart's data. |
| DC-T-034 | 7 Sep 2026 | We do not move this reading again before 31 October 2026 except on a condition met or new structural evidence | Closed, not scored Closed on 31 October, not scored: a rule we set ourselves. We said then that two of our moves on 3 October were arguable, so we did not grade it our way. | |
| DC-T-031 | 7 Sep 2026 | The S&P 500 moves more than 5 percent in either direction from its 4 September close before 31 October 2026 | 3 Nov 2026 (correction) | Wrong The S&P 500 stayed within 5 percent of its 4 September close of 7,718.60. When we opened the test we wrote that a sideways market would mean our reading was wrong; we closed it unscored on 30 October and correct that here. |
| DC-T-103 | 4 Sep 2026 | The Silicon Data token price index falls again in the September 2026 reading, making two consecutive monthly fallsIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-025 | 4 Sep 2026 | Semiconductors outperform software between now and 31 October 2026 | 31 Oct 2026 | Written against our caution. From 4 September the chip index fell 8.9 percent and the software fund IGV 0.3 percent, so chips did not outperform. |
| DC-T-021 | 3 Sep 2026 | The S&P 500 closes at or below 7,300 by 31 October 2026 | 31 Oct 2026 | Wrong The S&P 500 closed at 7,580.07 on 30 October, the last session, 3.8 percent above the line. |
| DC-T-007 | 3 Sep 2026 | The Federal Reserve raises its policy rate at the 16 September meeting | 17 Sep 2026 | Wrong The Fed raised by a quarter point to 3.75 to 4 percent on 16 September. We had said since 31 August that a hold was likelier. |
| DC-T-036 | 2 Sep 2026 | The signed but not commenced lease total rises above 450 billion dollars by 31 March 2027 | Closed, not scored Retired unscored on 19 October: published totals were already far above our line, so the test was badly set. | |
| DC-T-019 | 2 Sep 2026 | Combined hyperscaler free cash flow prints negative for the third quarter | 30 Oct 2026 | Combined free cash flow of the four builders was negative in the third quarter, about minus 26 billion dollars on our sum, on mixed definitions. |
| DC-T-017 | 1 Sep 2026 | September high grade corporate issuance reaches or exceeds 200 billion dollars | 26 Oct 2026 | Wrong JPMorgan counted 197 billion dollars of high grade issuance in September, just under our line. |
| DC-T-008 | 1 Sep 2026 | The ten year yield breaks above 5 percent by 31 October 2026 | 17 Sep 2026 | The ten year closed above 5 percent on 16 September on the session report we scored; one rates wrap had it at 5.00 percent, which we printed beside it. |
| DC-T-037 | 31 Aug 2026 | The August payroll report is negative, making two consecutive negative prints | Closed, not scored Closed on 7 September, resolved no. It was the condition behind our Fed position, which we booked as wrong on 17 September. | |
| DC-T-035 | 31 Aug 2026 | The investment grade credit default index breaks above 50 basis points | Closed, not scored Fired our way on 3 October, but the test had no date, so it moved our caution gauge, not the ledger. | |
| DC-T-104 | 29 Aug 2026 | Rental prices on older processors soften now that the vendor's own rental backstop has been pausedIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-102 | 29 Aug 2026 | The next two price prints keep the six month annualised rate above the twelve month oneIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-038 | 29 Aug 2026 | Gold falls more than 8 percent from 4,600 dollars while the Fed's tolerance of inflation is unchanged or rising | Closed, not scored Closed without firing on 3 September and kept for the record. | |
| DC-T-005 | 28 Aug 2026 | No hawkish surprise from Jackson HoleCall in plain English | 29 Aug 2026 | Wrong There was one, within a day. From that day our plain English calls count too. |
| DC-T-106 | 27 Aug 2026 | Nvidia receivables grow faster than revenue in the next filingIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-105 | 27 Aug 2026 | Free cash flow margin falls to a second consecutive quarter near or below 20 percentIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-109 | 26 Aug 2026 | A published humanoid to worker ratio falls below 1.8 by 31 August 2027If met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-018 | 26 Aug 2026 | The next quarterly filings show off balance sheet obligations still rising | 30 Oct 2026 | Unstarted leases at Meta, Microsoft, Alphabet and Amazon rose 185.2 billion dollars in the third quarter, our sum from their filings. We first marked this met in August on an earlier filing but did not book it then. |
| DC-T-004 | 26 Aug 2026 | Tonight's Nvidia reaction lands inside 5.4 percent (we argued it would not) | 27 Aug 2026 | Wrong The shares moved about 5 percent, inside the move the options market priced, for a ninth report in a row. |
| DC-T-108 | 25 Aug 2026 | Median business development company non accruals exceed 3.5 percentIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-107 | 25 Aug 2026 | Investment grade technology spreads stay wider than the broad market for four consecutive weeksIf met, it counts for us | Open Not fired as of 2 November 2026. | |
| DC-T-040 | 25 Aug 2026 | Urea or ammonia prices fail to rise by the end of September | Closed, not scored Retired unscored on 3 October at its deadline: no research we read gave a dated price. | |
| DC-T-039 | 25 Aug 2026 | Yields return above their pre buyback levels after the midterm elections | Closed, not scored Retired on 2 September as badly worded, the day after it moved against us. We booked nothing then and do not book it now. | |
| DC-T-032 | 25 Aug 2026 | Total tokens processed grow faster than unit prices fall for two consecutive quartersIf met, it counts against us | Open Not fired as of 3 November 2026. On 28 August our tripwire label said this test had fired against us, but our note that day called it unresolved, as January to July at one lab is not two quarters of total tokens. We correct the label, not the ledger. | |
| DC-T-006 | 25 Aug 2026 | The ten year yield falls toward 4.30 percent on a short covering squeeze | 1 Sep 2026 | Wrong The yield went about 45 basis points the other way. The test had no deadline; since 1 September every level we publish has a date. |
| DC-T-003 | 18 Aug 2026 | The twenty year Treasury auction stops above 5.245 percent | 20 Aug 2026 | Wrong It stopped at 5.204 percent and long yields fell about 9 basis points. |
| DC-T-002 | 11 Aug 2026 | Does expensive optimism survive the inflation reading and this week's auctions?Open question we scored | 13 Aug 2026 | Wrong It survived: inflation matched forecasts at 3.4 percent and the ten year auction cleared well. |
| DC-T-001 | 11 Aug 2026 | Professional investors are positioned against this rally (published with its invalidator: positioning rebuilds quickly)Thesis with a stated invalidator | 12 Aug 2026 | Wrong Citi reported positioning back to net long on fresh buying within a day, which was our own invalidator. |
Buy, Sell, Reduce and Avoid calls from our company reports, judged against the price and fair value in the original report. Hold and watchlist views are listed but not scored. Rows other than MP-TL-001 and MP-TL-021 were added on 2 and 3 November 2026 from the original reports, with their original dates and prices.
| ID | Published | Company · our view | Price when published | Close on 30 Oct | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MP-TL-021 | 26 Sep 2026 | $GOLDAvoid | USD 43.95 | USD 38.03−13.5% since; S&P 500 −2.1% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 13.5 percent below our reference price, but the call is five weeks into a 36 month horizon. The first results since our report are due on 4 November. |
| MP-TL-046 | 19 Sep 2026 | $MUReduce / Avoid | USD 1015.8 | USD 884.74−12.9% since; S&P 500 −0.9% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 13 percent below our reference, against a 1 percent fall in the S&P 500, but margins rose to 87 percent and most 2027 output is under contract, so the cycle turn behind our view has not arrived. We are still watching. |
| MP-TL-045 | 13 Sep 2026 | $BMWBuy | EUR 63 | EUR 57.80−8.3% since; S&P 500 −1.0% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 8 percent below our buy price and third quarter China deliveries fell 25 percent, while Europe and the US grew. Our main test, realised pricing in the first half of 2027, has not arrived, so we are still watching. |
| MP-TL-044 | 13 Sep 2026 | $ORCLAvoid | USD 158.78 | USD 130.67−17.7% since; S&P 500 −1.0% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 Oracle is 13 percent below its last close before our report, against a 1 percent fall in the S&P 500, as debt worries grew. It is still above our $130 avoid line and its new funding cap answers part of our concern, so we are still watching. |
| MP-TL-043 | 07 Sep 2026 | $NLSTSell | USD 5.02 | USD 6.32+25.9% since; S&P 500 −1.8% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 26 percent above our sell price and more than double our $2.74 bull case, after Micron agreed to pay $600 million for a licence, far more than the patent value we assumed. The call looks wrong. |
| MP-TL-042 | 30 Aug 2026 | $EDRYSell | USD 50.38 | USD 44.31−12.0% since; S&P 500 −1.7% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 12 percent below our reference and 6 percent above our $41.68 target, after first spiking above our bull case in September. Ship values have not yet fallen, so we are still watching. |
| MP-TL-041 | 22 Aug 2026 | $MRNASell | USD 145.13 | USD 221.72+52.8% since; S&P 500 −1.2% | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 we close this call as wrong: the shares closed at $221.72, 53 percent above our Sell price and 44 percent above our $154.02 bull case, after the full phase 3 data held up. |
| MP-TL-040 | 15 Aug 2026 | $PGYHold | USD 21.56 | USD 19.23−10.8% since; S&P 500 −2.6% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 11 percent below our Hold price, against a 3 percent fall in the S&P 500. We do not score Hold views. The take rate we watch slipped to 4.1 percent, just above our 4.0 percent warning line. |
| MP-TL-039 | 09 Aug 2026 | $OOMAStatistical Sell | USD 21.97 | USD 19.91−9.4% since; S&P 500 −2.3% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 9 percent below our reference, but the 26 August results passed the test we set: GAAP operating margin rose to 4.8 percent from 1.4 percent as revenue grew 25 percent, so the evidence now runs against our sell case. |
| MP-TL-038 | 02 Aug 2026 | $WEAVReduce | USD 6.54 | USD 7.40+13.1% since; S&P 500 +1.2% | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 this call is closed as wrong: Francisco Partners bought Weave for $7.40 a share in cash, 13 percent above our Reduce price and above our $5.44 fair value. The August results had briefly pushed the shares below that value. |
| MP-TL-037 | 26 Jul 2026 | $LNVGYHold | USD 61.89 | USD 50.81−17.9% since; S&P 500 +2.3% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 18 percent below our Hold price, after server margins beat our upgrade test and the shares passed our $75 trim level in September before falling on weak PC sales. We do not score Hold views. |
| MP-TL-036 | 24 Jul 2026 | $HONAWatchlist | USD 195.87 | USD 154.15−21.3% since; S&P 500 +2.3% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 21 percent below our $195.87 Watchlist price, after an August guidance cut sent them straight through our $176 to $178 entry zone. Our caution has been borne out so far, but we do not score Watchlist views. |
| MP-TL-035 | 19 Jul 2026 | $FROHold | USD 36.49 | USD 56.90+55.9% since; S&P 500 +1.6% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 56 percent above our Hold price and close to our $60.06 bull case, as tanker rates and dividends stayed high. A Hold at fair value is not scored, but our view that the shares were fully priced has not worked so far. |
| MP-TL-001 | 11 Jul 2026 | $INDVStrong Buy | $40.50 | 35.37−12.7% since; S&P 500 +0.1% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 Indivior has beaten our margin and cash case, but the shares are 12.7 percent below our reference price and the Supernus merger replaces the company we analysed. Not final. |
| MP-TL-002 | 05 Jul 2026 | $CNCBuy | $68.30 | 68.45+0.2% since; S&P 500 +1.3% | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 Centene passed our benefits ratio test in July and raised guidance twice, but its third quarter ratio rose to 92.7 percent and the shares are flat, so the case stays open. |
| MP-TL-034 | 27 Jun 2026 | $SEZLSell / Reduce | USD 170.56 | USD 134.85−20.9% since; S&P 500 +3.1% | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 21 percent below our Sell price, against a 3 percent rise in the S&P 500, after Sezzle guided to slower growth in the second half. They still sit above our $103.72 bull case value, so the call is only partly right so far. |
| MP-TL-003 | 22 Jun 2026 | $SNDKSell / Avoid | $2,184.75 | 1150.89−47.3% since; S&P 500 +1.4% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 47.3 percent below our reference price but still above our 1,119 dollar bull case value, and margins have kept rising, so the cycle turn we expect has not arrived. |
| MP-TL-004 | 15 Jun 2026 | $ADBEStrong Buy | $204.02 | 250.23+22.6% since; S&P 500 +0.3% | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 22.6 percent above our reference price against a flat S&P 500, with record cash flow. AI worries returned in October, so the case stays open. |
| MP-TL-005 | 08 Jun 2026 | $EQTBuy / Accumulate | $53.94 | 55.38+2.7% since; S&P 500 +2.4% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 2.7 percent above our reference price, in line with the S&P 500, and unit costs stayed at the low end of guidance. The re-rating we expected has not come yet. |
| MP-TL-006 | 01 Jun 2026 | $ACNStrong Buy | $187.85 | 258.24+37.5% since; S&P 500 −0.3% | As of 30 October 2026 we close this call as right: the shares are 37 percent above our $187.85 Strong Buy price and above our $240.58 base case value after full year results beat guidance. In June they fell to $124.44, below our $163 bear case. |
| MP-TL-033 | 26 May 2026 | $MOHWatchlist | USD 184 | USD 204.78+11.3% since; S&P 500 +0.8% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 11 percent above our $184 reference and never reached our $155 to $165 buy zone. Molina's third quarter medical cost ratio was 92.9 percent, exactly the line at which we said we would close the fast recovery case. |
| MP-TL-007 | 25 May 2026 | $GEHold; trim above 340 USD | $302.84 | 301.80−0.3% since; S&P 500 +1.4% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are flat since our Hold. They closed near 381 dollars on 5 August, above the 340 dollar level where we said to trim, then fell back to about 302. |
| MP-TL-008 | 18 May 2026 | $BSXBuy | $52.75 | 41.98−20.4% since; S&P 500 +2.4% | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 our own test has failed: electrophysiology sales fell 5 percent in the third quarter, below the 6 to 7 percent floor we set. The shares are 20.4 percent below our price. |
| MP-TL-009 | 11 May 2026 | $NEEHold / Wait | $96.95 | 83.71−13.7% since; S&P 500 +2.3% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 13.7 percent below our reference price while the S&P 500 rose 2.3 percent, and they have traded through the 80 to 85 dollar range where we planned to buy. |
| MP-TL-010 | 04 May 2026 | $ASMLAvoid / valuation risk | $1,427.02 | 1565.90+9.7% since; S&P 500 +5.3% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 9.7 percent above our Avoid price, ahead of the S&P 500, and ASML expects 2027 and 2028 demand to exceed its supply, the opposite of the slowdown we expected. |
| MP-TL-032 | 27 Apr 2026 | $ASTStrong Buy | PLN 47.95 | PLN 30.15−37.1% since; S&P 500 +5.7% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 37 percent below our 47.95 PLN reference. Half-year EBITDA fell 58 percent, leverage rose to 4.1 times and Russian attacks disrupted Black Sea exports, so our deep value case looks wrong so far. |
| MP-TL-011 | 20 Apr 2026 | $NHY.OLReduce | NOK 102.80 | NOK 66.14−35.7% since; S&P 500 +6.6% | As of 30 October 2026 the shares were 35.7 percent below our Reduce price, after first rising to about 119 kroner in June. Much of the fall came as aluminium lost its war premium, not only from the alumina profits we flagged. |
| MP-TL-012 | 13 Apr 2026 | $INVE-B.STHold | SEK 373.80 | SEK 427.10+14.3% since; S&P 500 +10.1% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 14.3 percent above our reference price, against 10.1 percent for the S&P 500, and never fell to the 340 kronor level where we said we would buy. |
| MP-TL-013 | 06 Apr 2026 | $STMSell | $33.73 | 46.74+38.6% since; S&P 500 +14.6% | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 38.6 percent above our Sell price, against 14.6 percent for the S&P 500. The recovery we doubted showed up within our own test window, so we mark this call wrong. |
| MP-TL-014 | 30 Mar 2026 | $LITEAvoid / Reduce | $702.73 | 840.70+19.6% since; S&P 500 +19.5% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 19.6 percent above our Avoid price, level with the S&P 500, and revenue has more than doubled. We set no end date, so the result is not final. |
| MP-TL-015 | 23 Mar 2026 | $FICOSell / Take Profits | $1,127.62 | 711.23−36.9% since; S&P 500 +15.2% | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 this call stays closed as wrong, as we decided earlier this year. The shares were 21.8 percent above our price on 29 July, when FICO raised guidance for the second time, and are 36.9 percent below it now. |
| MP-TL-016 | 16 Mar 2026 | $AMTMBuy / Accumulate at 22 to 28 USD | $28 | 21.87−21.9% since; S&P 500 +13.1% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 21.9 percent below our reference price and closed below our bear case in September. Cash flow guidance held but revenue guidance was cut; results are due on 24 November. |
| MP-TL-017 | 09 Mar 2026 | $3110.TStrong Sell | ¥4,762 (5-for-1 split adjusted) | ¥4,762 2814.50−40.9% since; S&P 500 +11.5% | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 the shares closed at 2,814.5 yen, after rising to 6,390 yen in May and falling around the May and August results. They remain above our fair value range, but profits are growing faster than we expected. |
| MP-TL-018 | 02 Mar 2026 | $VRSNHold / Wait; accumulate 190 to 205 USD | $227.94 | 307.21+34.8% since; S&P 500 +10.1% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 34.8 percent above our reference price, against 10.1 percent for the S&P 500, as domain growth sped up. Our view that the shares were fully priced has not worked so far. |
| MP-TL-019 | 23 Feb 2026 | $PANWHold / Wait | $149 | 365.87+145.6% since; S&P 500 +10.9% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 145.6 percent above our reference price, against 10.9 percent for the S&P 500. They never fell to our entry zone, so our advice to wait missed the rise. |
| MP-TL-020 | 14 Feb 2026 | $OKTABuy / re-rating thesis | $87.26 | 208.24+138.6% since; S&P 500 +10.9% | Closed as right. As of 30 October 2026 the shares were 138.6 percent above our reference price and above our 199 dollar bull case. Backlog growth held above our 13 percent floor; free cash flow margins slipped from a high base. |
| MP-TL-031 | 08 Feb 2026 | $PUMPBuy | USD 11.24 | USD 7.73−31.2% since; S&P 500 +9.3% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 31 percent below our reference price, against a 9 percent rise in the S&P 500, after briefly closing above our $16.44 fair value in April. None of our three warning signs has fired, but the call looks wrong so far. |
| MP-TL-030 | 04 Feb 2026 | $KYIVStrong Buy | USD 11.82 | USD 12.93+9.4% since; S&P 500 +10.1% | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 9 percent above our reference, in line with the S&P 500 and far from our $21 to $23 target. Revenue growth has stayed above our 10 percent floor and no invalidation trigger has fired, so the call stays open. |
| MP-TL-029 | 27 Jan 2026 | $SMRHold | USD 19.77 | USD 5.62−71.6% since; S&P 500 +8.6% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we do not score this Hold. For the record, the shares are 72 percent below our reference and well below our $9.80 bear case, as the Romanian project stalled and share sales far exceeded our estimate. |
| MP-TL-028 | 26 Jan 2026 | $DGEHold | GBp 1675 | GBp 1757.00+4.9% since; S&P 500 +9.1% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we do not score this Hold. For the record, the shares dipped into our 1,400p to 1,500p buying zone in March and are back near our 1,746p fair value, but the dividend at the core of the case was cut by about half. |
| MP-TL-027 | 22 Jan 2026 | $PMHold / Wait | USD 168.81 | USD 208.79+23.7% since; S&P 500 +9.6% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we do not score this Hold. For the record, the shares are 24 percent above our reference and 38 percent above our $151 bull case, so our view that every scenario implied downside has not worked. |
| MP-TL-026 | 20 Jan 2026 | $ITXSell / Reduce | EUR 55.96 | EUR 56.14+0.3% since; S&P 500 +11.5% | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are flat against our reference rather than lower, and Inditex passed the margin and growth tests we set for the spring. They did dip into our 48 to 50 euros buying zone in May, and our 12-month window runs to January 2027. |
| MP-TL-025 | 14 Jan 2026 | $EPAMAccumulate | USD 211.99 | USD 140.51−33.7% since; S&P 500 +9.4% | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 the shares are 34 percent below our reference and below our $177 bear case, and 2026 revenue growth has been guided to 3 to 4 percent, under the 10 percent our bear case named, so we close this call as wrong. |
| MP-TL-024 | 13 Jan 2026 | $BTIHold / Buy on dips | USD 55.68 | USD 61.52+10.5% since; S&P 500 +8.9% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 our Hold was a neutral income view, so we do not score it. The shares rose 10 percent, in line with the S&P 500, without reaching our $48 to $50 buying level, while cigarette volumes fell faster than the 2 percent we modelled. |
| MP-TL-023 | 11 Jan 2026 | $RHMHold / Take profit | EUR 1835 | EUR 1037.60−43.5% since; S&P 500 +8.8% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we do not score this Hold. For the record, the shares are 43 percent below our reference and below our 1,400 to 1,700 euro fair value range, so the advice to take profit held, but our re-entry zone proved too high. |
| MP-TL-022 | 10 Jan 2026 | $CRMHold | USD 260.63 | USD 229.17−12.1% since; S&P 500 +8.8% | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we do not score this Hold. For the record, the shares are 12 percent below our reference while the S&P 500 rose 9 percent; they fell through our $240 to $245 entry zone to $150 in June. |
Calls from our macro, market and theme reports, each judged against the test or range in the original report. Added to the register on 3 November 2026 from the original reports.
| ID | Published | Theme · our call | Test | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MP-MC-083 | 27 Sep 2026 | AI and financial data: no entry pointsNo good entry points in FactSet, LSEG or MSCI; interest zones at $228, 79.46 pounds and $325 | None: explicitly not a callMeasured on: FDS, LSEG.L and MSCI | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: we said there were no good entry points. Since then FactSet rose 21 percent, LSEG 16 percent and MSCI 13 percent, and none fell to our interest zones, so our caution has not worked so far. |
| MP-MC-082 | 19 Sep 2026 | Geothermal arbitrage: watch on FervoWatch on Fervo until commercial proof; weighted value $7.22 against a $16.91 price | None: watch and hold stancesMeasured on: FRVO | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: our stance on Fervo was watch, not avoid. For the record, the shares fell 51 percent from our $16.91 reference to $8.28, close to our $7.22 weighted value, so our caution held, but we do not count it as a win. |
| MP-MC-080 | 7 Sep 2026 | Value ETFs: what the labels ownScores value funds on economic value; no stock met the 13 percent hurdle, with PayPal closest at a $52.4 interest zone | None: fund scores and role preferencesMeasured on: PYPL | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: the report explained what value funds hold and found no stock that met our hurdle. For the record, PayPal, the closest candidate, is up 4 percent since publication at $57.01, after briefly closing below our $52.4 interest zone in September. |
| MP-MC-079 | 30 Aug 2026 | European banks after the re-ratingThe sector trade is over: build BNP Paribas, Barclays and UniCredit gradually, avoid Commerzbank and UBS, keep Apple and Meta | Stance held to the end of Q1 2027 unless cost of risk, the French spread or tech cash flow turns against itMeasured on: Named banks against EXV1.DE; AAPL and META | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 BNP Paribas, Barclays and UniCredit, the banks we said to build, are down 14 to 16.5 percent since our call, worse than the sector fund at 12 percent, while Commerzbank and UBS, which we avoid, fell 7 and 12 percent. Apple and Meta, which we kept, rose 8 and 6 percent. |
| MP-MC-078 | 20 Aug 2026 | Grain is cheap, capital is expensiveNot yet an agricultural supercycle in 2026; own mispriced balance sheets such as CNH over crop tickers such as WEAT | No trigger; 2026 horizonMeasured on: WEAT, CORN and DBA; CNH | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 grain funds are 5 to 13 percent lower since our call and the USDA raised its US corn crop estimate, in line with our view that this is not a supercycle. CNH, our best asymmetry, is up 7 percent, while Bunge fell 17 percent. The 2026 window is open. |
| MP-MC-077 | 17 Aug 2026 | AI-labour liquidity gapAI reaches the P&L as a cost before it shows up as a saving; value shifts out of BPO and IT services into infrastructure | None: revisit conditions to mid-2027Measured on: ACN | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: the report described AI as a cost rather than a saving and set conditions to revisit it, not a market call. For the record, Accenture, an IT services name of the kind we said was losing value to clients, rose 52 percent after publication. |
| MP-MC-076 | 13 Aug 2026 | Phantom gigawatts: protected suppliers over neocloudsPrefer GE Vernova and Vistra over financing-dependent developers; avoid Nebius and Powell | No test or horizonMeasured on: GEV and VST against NBIS, POWL and the S&P 500 | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 Nebius and Powell, which we said to avoid, are down 40 and 23 percent since our call, with Nebius hit by debt worries across AI cloud firms. GE Vernova and Vistra, which we preferred, also fell 18 and 5.5 percent, behind the S&P 500, which fell 3 percent. |
| MP-MC-075 | 6 Aug 2026 | FCX: wait for $41 to $43Structurally bullish copper, but FCX is a valuation trap at $62.63; wait for $41 to $43 | None: a wait view with an entry rangeMeasured on: FCX | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: we said wait for $41 to $43 rather than sell. The shares are 8 percent lower than on publication day at $62.47 and never came near our entry range, after closing as high as $79.91 in August, above our $70 bull case. |
| MP-MC-074 | 31 Jul 2026 | Earnings quality: Alphabet and TeslaAlphabet's and Tesla's record profits were not really there, and Big Tech is shifting to costly external funding | Voids if Alphabet restarts $15 billion plus of buybacks on positive free cash flow without new debtMeasured on: GOOGL and TSLA; SPCX mark | Too early As of 30 October 2026 Alphabet is down 21 percent since our call, falling 13 percent after third-quarter results amid AI spending fears, and we could not yet confirm whether buybacks restarted, the test that would void our view. Tesla rose 28.5 percent, against our view. |
| MP-MC-073 | 29 Jul 2026 | When the agent becomes the userAI value migrates to the enterprise control plane; screen for cash yields above 2 percent | None: a screening ruleMeasured on: IGV; CIBR | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: the report argued that value moves to the enterprise control plane but named no asset, level or horizon to test. For the record, software and cyber security funds rose 13 and 14 percent after publication. |
| MP-MC-071 | 21 Jul 2026 | Hormuz trap: refiners and tankers over the NasdaqLong refiners (VLO, MPC, PSX) and product tankers (STNG, ASC) against long-duration tech (QQQ, SOXX) | Fails if shipping normalises and cracks hold below $30; thresholds of cracks above $40 and gasoline above $4Measured on: Refiners and tankers against QQQ and SOXX | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 refiners are up 27 to 39 percent and product tankers 16 to 29 percent since our call, while the Nasdaq 100 fund fell 3 percent and the chip fund (SOXX) 15 percent. Crack spreads stayed above $50 and gasoline above $4 throughout, so our failure test has not fired. |
| MP-MC-068 | 21 Jul 2026 | AI capex as a credit assetThe cost of keeping the AI build-out intact has risen and credit prices it before earnings; leveraged names such as Oracle and CoreWeave sit at the edge | No published test; 6 to 18 month scenariosMeasured on: US investment-grade spreads (FRED); ORCL, CRWV and NBIS; MSFT | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 credit has tightened: US investment-grade spreads widened from 78 to 94 basis points since our call and CoreWeave and Nebius fell about 30 percent amid debt worries, while Microsoft rose 31 percent. Oracle, our lead example, is up 3 percent. There has been no systemic break. |
| MP-MC-066 | 18 Jul 2026 | Longevity economy: the data interface over the labFavour the interface that owns the data archive, treat labs as mature utilities and keep speculative names small | None: a framework with 2026 to 2029 scenariosMeasured on: HIMS against LH and DGX | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: we favoured data platforms over labs in principle but named no buy, level or horizon. For the record, Labcorp and Quest rose 28 and 20 percent after publication while Hims fell 16 percent, the opposite of what the framework implied. |
| MP-MC-065 | 16 Jul 2026 | Humanoid bottleneck: physical AI as a satelliteKeep physical AI a small satellite; pure plays are priced for near-flawless execution | None: a sizing view with 2030 scenariosMeasured on: BOTZ; LeaderDrive and UBTech | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: we kept humanoid robotics as a small satellite and named no level. For the record, the robotics ETF (BOTZ) fell 9 percent after publication. |
| MP-MC-063 | 11 Jul 2026 | Dismantling the Fed PutHigher for longer is the floor, crowded semis are most at risk and the structural defences are gold, equal weight, GM and FCX over 6 to 18 months | No test; 6 to 18 month window with the base case to mid-2027Measured on: Fed funds target; SMH; RSP against the S&P 500; GLD | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 the Fed has raised rates once to 3.75 to 4 percent rather than cut, and the crowded chip trade (SMH) fell 14.5 percent since our call. Equal weight beat the S&P 500 by about 2 points, but gold, one of our defences, fell 6 percent. The window runs to mid-2027. |
| MP-MC-061 | 7 Jul 2026 | Healthcare last mile: five small caps by roleSorts WGS, URGN, STAA, MDWD and IMDX into prove-it, turnaround and small option roles | None: roles and sizing, no direction or levelMeasured on: The five named stocks | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we score this as no clear call: the report sorted five small caps into roles but set no direction or test. For the record, four of the five fell after publication, and Insight Molecular, which we said to keep small, fell 40 percent. |
| MP-MC-058 | 25 Jun 2026 | Contrarian havens: a cash-flow sleeveA 12 to 15 percent sleeve of Lamar, Outfront, Ares Capital, Blue Owl and Japan (EWJ, DXJ) as tangible cash flow against crowded AI megacaps | No test or horizon; bear marker a credit shock with 4 to 5 percent defaults and a 25 to 40 percent drawdownMeasured on: Sleeve at the stated weights against the S&P 500 | Too early As of 30 October 2026 our cash flow sleeve is up about 2 percent on price since our call against 3 percent for the S&P 500, roughly level once dividends are counted. Ares now trades near asset value, while Blue Owl's discount widened to about 27 percent. There has been no credit shock so far. |
| MP-MC-057 | 22 Jun 2026 | Defence tech: integrators over commodity hardwarePrefer integrators and software, with Palantir as the benchmark, over commodity hardware, with AeroVironment as the cautionary tale, through 2026 | No test; 2026 scenario matrixMeasured on: PLTR against AVAV; KTOS as a named scenario winner | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 Palantir, our software benchmark, is up 54 percent since our call and AeroVironment, our hardware warning, is down 17 percent, partly on company-specific setbacks. Kratos, a named scenario winner, fell 20 percent. Our 2026 window is still open. |
| MP-MC-054 | 22 May 2026 | AI and labour: the human ring (ACN, ISRG)Buy the human ring that gets stronger: Accenture and Intuitive Surgical are asymmetric | Exit triggers only (models take legal responsibility, AI pricing falls to zero, data centre growth stops outpacing depreciation); framed to 2034Measured on: ACN and ISRG | Too early As of 30 October 2026 Accenture is up 44 percent and Intuitive Surgical down 1 percent since our call, and none of our exit triggers has fired. With one name up and one down in a call framed to 2034, it is too early to score. |
| MP-MC-052 | 15 May 2026 | European luxury basketBasket of the GLUX ETF (50 percent), Brunello Cucinelli, LVMH and Kering for plus 18 percent in 12 months, with exit levels | Plus 18 percent in 12 months; exits LVMH below 395 euros, Cucinelli below 70 euros, Kering at 170 to 185 eurosMeasured on: Weighted basket (GLUX.MI, BC.MI, MC.PA, KER.PA) | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 our luxury basket is down about 1 percent since our call against a 12-month aim of plus 18 percent, and two of our exit levels, LVMH below 395 euros and Kering at 170 to 185 euros, have been hit. Brunello Cucinelli held up. The window runs to May 2027. |
| MP-MC-050 | 14 May 2026 | B2B trade-down: cautious on SyscoWould not buy the Sysco dip after the Jetro deal; base case sideways for three years, with Performance Food and US Foods as beneficiaries | Sysco sideways for three years; bear case an FTC block or customer defection to USFD and PFGCMeasured on: SYY against PFGC, USFD and the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 Sysco is up 13.5 percent since our call, well ahead of the S&P 500. Of the two rivals we expected to gain from its Jetro deal, US Foods rose more (23 percent) and Performance Food less (2 percent). No FTC block has been reported, so our cautious view is looking wrong for now. |
| MP-MC-048 | 11 May 2026 | Pharma manufacturing suppliers (the arms dealers)The next decade in pharma is decided in the factory: position with Thermo Fisher, Danaher, West, Lonza and Sartorius | No test or level; a direction over the next decadeMeasured on: Equal-weight five suppliers against the S&P 500 and XLV | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the five manufacturing suppliers we favoured are up about 38 percent on average since our call in local currency, against 2 percent for the S&P 500 and 29 percent for US health care (XLV). On price alone, six months into a call framed over a decade, we are still watching. |
| MP-MC-046 | 6 May 2026 | Two-speed consumer: membership winners over the middle tierBuy both ends, sell the middle: own Walmart, Costco, TJX, Ross and Netflix, hold no middle-tier apparel such as Kohl's and Macy's, wait for Five Below at $140 to 160 | Winners beat the middle tier over 2026 to 2030; Five Below entry at $140 to 160Measured on: Five winners against KSS and M; FIVE entry band | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 Kohl's and Macy's, the middle tier we said to avoid, are up about 45 percent since our call, while our five membership winners average a 10 percent fall from end April. Five Below did not fall to our entry range. Our window runs to 2030, but the call is running against us. |
| MP-MC-044 | 4 May 2026 | Gold liquidity shockGold's fall is a liquidity dip, not a bear-market reversal; position into the squeeze | Invalidation if the 10-year real yield tops 2.5 percent, the dollar spikes on liquidity stress or sovereigns sell goldMeasured on: Gold futures (GC=F) and GLD; 10-year real yield | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 we mark this call wrong. The 10-year real yield rose above 2.5 percent in September, the level we named as our invalidation trigger, and gold futures are 14 percent lower than when we published. Our other two triggers, dollar stress and central bank selling, did not fire. |
| MP-MC-042 | 1 May 2026 | Servers on wheels: AI silicon over carmakersNvidia and Qualcomm win whoever controls the driveway; stay sceptical of Volkswagen and GM as hardware-only traps | Chip pair beats the carmaker pair over 2026 to 2028; no levelMeasured on: NVDA and QCOM against VWAGY and GM | Too early As of 30 October 2026 Nvidia and Qualcomm are down about 2 percent on average since our call and Volkswagen and GM about 5 percent, but GM rose 15 percent while VW fell 25 percent. The gap we expected is not clear yet. |
| MP-MC-040 | 29 Apr 2026 | Digital health: the wellness basketA 12-stock wellness basket, with Lilly and Novo Nordisk the largest sleeve, beats the S&P 500 by 300 to 500 basis points in the base case | Basket beats the S&P 500 by 300 to 500 basis points; bull case Lilly above $1,500; invalidation on a CMS-mandated 50 percent GLP-1 price cut or 15 percent Gen Z dumb-phone adoptionMeasured on: Model basket against the S&P 500; Lilly above $1,500 as the bull marker | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 Lilly is up 67 percent since our call and Novo Nordisk is flat, against 6 percent for the S&P 500, and from end April our 12-stock basket is up 11 percent against 5 percent for the index. Lilly has not passed $1,500 and neither invalidation trigger has fired. |
| MP-MC-038 | 25 Apr 2026 | Physical scarcity barbell (Picks and Shovels 2.0)2026 barbell of Bunge, CF, Xylem, Ecolab, Badger Meter and Mueller Water with targets and stops; short Deere; avoid MOO | Per-name targets and stops (for example Bunge $170 and $108); 2026 horizonMeasured on: Named stocks against their own targets and stops; Deere short | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 stops have been hit on Bunge, Xylem and Mueller Water, 37 percent of our barbell, and the Deere short is 20 percent against us since our call. Badger Meter touched its $150 target in October and CF and Ecolab are still open, so the call is looking wrong rather than closed. |
| MP-MC-036 | 22 Apr 2026 | Market structure and liquidity: the illusion of safetyCalm markets hide fragility and the eventual repricing will be more violent; conditional rotation rules | None: no level, date or testMeasured on: S&P 500; VIX | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we do not score this report. It argued that calm markets hid fragility but set no level, date or test that can be checked. For the record, the S&P 500 is up 6 percent since publication and the VIX is about where it was. |
| MP-MC-034 | 18 Apr 2026 | US housing and mortgage rates: the Great RiftMortgage rates fall 25 to 40 basis points once bond volatility subsides; own PulteGroup, Rocket, AMH and other real-asset names over 2026 to 2028 | Mortgage rates 25 to 40 basis points lower; 24-month scenario windowMeasured on: 30-year mortgage rate (Freddie Mac); XHB and VNQ against the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the 30-year mortgage rate is 7.24 percent, above the 6.46 percent we cited, instead of 25 to 40 basis points lower. Homebuilder and REIT funds fell 6 and 3 percent since our call while the S&P 500 rose 6 percent. Our 24-month window is still open. |
| MP-MC-032 | 15 Apr 2026 | Nuclear fuel: the HALEU basketWeighted HALEU basket: Cameco 30, Centrus 25, URA 15, ASP Isotopes 15, BWXT and others 15 percent | ASPI scenarios bull $12 to 20, base $5 to 8, bear $1 to 3; South African licence decision as the 2026 catalystMeasured on: CCJ, LEU, URA and ASPI against the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the HALEU names we favoured have fallen hard since our call: Cameco is down 35 percent, Centrus 48 percent and ASP Isotopes 62 percent, while the S&P 500 rose 8 percent. Uranium contract prices firmed, but the South African licence decision we flagged is still pending. |
| MP-MC-030 | 10 Apr 2026 | Cybersecurity: Palo Alto NetworksBuy PANW in the $146 to $155 zone with a stop below $130 and a $207 target | Target $207; stop below $130; invalidation if CrowdStrike gross retention falls 200 basis points or open-source AI commoditises securityMeasured on: PANW; CIBR | As of 30 October 2026 Palo Alto closed at $365.87, up 135 percent since our call and well past our $207 target. It never neared our $130 stop. The cyber ETF we use as a proxy rose 66 percent against 11 percent for the S&P 500. On the day we published the shares closed just above our buy zone. |
| MP-MC-028 | 7 Apr 2026 | The boring barbell: habit platforms and defensivesBarbell of McDonald's and Starbucks with Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, P&G and Colgate; avoid apparel-cycle names | No stated test or horizon; implied rotation into the barbell ahead of the marketMeasured on: Equal-weight MCD, SBUX, KO, PEP, PG and CL against the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 our six-stock barbell is up about 6 percent on an equal-weight basis since our call, against 15 percent for the S&P 500. Coca-Cola led, but McDonald's and PepsiCo fell, so the rotation we described has not paid off so far. |
| MP-MC-026 | 3 Apr 2026 | Information services: the mispriced moat (SPGI, MCO)Own the fortresses, above all S&P Global and Moody's; Thomson Reuters faces seat-count risk | Abort if Q3 or Q4 2026 issuance weakens sharply, the CFPB caps score pricing or seat contraction tops 10 percent; base case 15 to 25 percent returnsMeasured on: SPGI and MCO against the S&P 500 and TRI | Too early As of 30 October 2026 S&P Global is up 14 percent and Moody's 12 percent since our call, a little behind the S&P 500 at 15 percent, and none of our abort triggers has fired. Thomson Reuters, which we flagged as exposed, rose 31 percent, so the case is not proven yet. |
| MP-MC-025 | 31 Mar 2026 | US gas-advantaged chemicals (CF, Westlake)CF and Westlake as 3 to 6 month tactical longs with Linde as an anchor; avoid Mosaic | CF and WLK gain over 3 to 6 months; the easy part is over if ISM falls below 48 or Henry Hub holds above $4.50Measured on: CF, WLK, LIN and MOS against the S&P 500 | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 our three to six month long in CF and Westlake did not work: by late September CF was 11 percent and Westlake 47 percent below their end of March prices while the S&P 500 rose 17 percent. Mosaic, which we warned against, fell 15 percent over the same six months. |
| MP-MC-024 | 27 Mar 2026 | HALO: heavy assets over asset-lightHeavy assets with low obsolescence beat asset-light software; Tier 1 core Nvidia, GE Vernova, Vistra and Constellation | Core HALO names outperform; no horizon or triggerMeasured on: Equal-weight NVDA, GEV, VST and CEG against the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the heavy asset trade is running against us: our four core names are flat on average since our call, with Vistra down 11 percent and Constellation 13 percent, while the S&P 500 rose 19 percent. The thesis has no end date. |
| MP-MC-023 | 24 Mar 2026 | Hormuz disruption: the Great De-RiskingThe market is mispricing the Hormuz disruption as temporary; favour fee-based midstream (WMB, MPLX, EPD) and industrial gases (APD, LIN) | Scenarios: base an 8 to 20 week blockade with Brent $95 to 115; bull de-escalation by April; bear 6 months plus with Brent above $130Measured on: Brent; Hormuz flows; WMB, EPD, APD and LIN against the S&P 500 | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the evidence is mixed. The strait reopened in June and, despite a disrupted summer, Middle East crude exports were near pre-war levels by September before tension returned. Brent is up 13 percent since our call, but our pipeline and industrial gas names trailed the S&P 500. |
| MP-MC-022 | 20 Mar 2026 | Treasury buyer strike and real assetsA buyer strike in long-dated Treasuries weakens TLT and IEF; lean to gold, copper, uranium, defence and crypto-dollar names | Long Treasuries weaken; regime shifts if core PCE tops 3.5 percent or USD/CNY breaks below 6.50; no horizonMeasured on: 10-year yield and TLT; gold, copper and URA | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 our bond call has worked: the 10-year yield has risen from 4.39 to 4.93 percent since our call and TLT is down 5 percent. Our real asset picks are mixed: copper is up 21 percent, but gold is down 15 percent and uranium miners (URA) 27 percent. |
| MP-MC-021 | 17 Mar 2026 | India paradox: defensive on Indian equitiesBase case a 10 to 15 percent NIFTY correction with the rupee at 93 to 94; bear case oil above $120 and the rupee beyond 95; hedge with puts and gold | A 10 to 15 percent NIFTY correction; no horizonMeasured on: NIFTY 50; INDA against the S&P 500; USD/INR | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 India has lagged: the INDA fund is down 2 percent since our call against a 13 percent rise in the S&P 500 and the rupee is past 95 per dollar, but the NIFTY is only 2 percent lower, not the 10 to 15 percent fall we expected. |
| MP-MC-020 | 13 Mar 2026 | European dividend havens over US growthEuropean dividend payers (Handelsbanken, FDJ, BTI and a dividend ETF) offer 8 to 11 percent total returns as capital leaves US growth, helped by the euro | 8 to 11 percent expected total return; reassess on a sustained EUR/USD break below 1.10Measured on: VGK against SPY; BTI; EUR/USD | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the rotation has not happened: since our call the S&P 500 fund (SPY) is up 14 percent against 6.5 percent for the Europe fund (VGK) and the euro is down 3 percent, though BTI is up 3 percent before dividends. The euro is above the 1.10 level we flagged. |
| MP-MC-019 | 10 Mar 2026 | Fortress Europe: euro, defence primes and EU banksEUR/USD to 1.25 to 1.30 over 24 to 36 months; European defence primes to outperform by 30 to 50 percent in the base case | EUR/USD at 1.25 to 1.30 within 24 to 36 months; alert triggers at a BTP-Bund spread above 150 basis points or a German court blockMeasured on: EUR/USD; Rheinmetall, Thales and Leonardo against the Euro Stoxx 50 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 this is running against us: the euro is down 4 percent since our call to about 1.12 dollars, not moving towards 1.25. The defence names we favoured fell (Rheinmetall down 37 percent) while the Euro Stoxx 50 rose 5 percent. Our 24 to 36 month currency window is open. |
| MP-MC-018 | 6 Mar 2026 | EU carbon market and the green deadlockThe 90 euro EUA consensus is dead; revised range 60 to 75 euros, with a sustained break below 65 euros confirming the bear case | EUA in a 60 to 75 euro range; break below 65 euros validates; ETS modification is the exit; no horizonMeasured on: December 2026 EUA contract (broker commentary); KRBN | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the carbon price has recovered: the December 2026 EU allowance traded at 84.50 euros on 23 October, above our revised 60 to 75 euro range, and the KRBN carbon fund is up 20.5 percent since our call. We set no end date, so the call stays open. |
| MP-MC-017 | 3 Mar 2026 | Korea Value Up and the KOSPIKOSPI re-rating upside is nearly priced in near 6,300; wait for Q1 and Q2 earnings stability and position for dispersion within Korea, not the index | None scoreable: a wait view with no level or horizon for the indexMeasured on: KOSPI (^KS11) | Not scored As of 30 October 2026 we list this as no clear call: we said to wait for earnings stability and to position within Korea, not the index, a view we do not score. For the record, the KOSPI rallied to 9,386 in June but is 1 percent below its level when we published, while the S&P 500 rose 11 percent. |
| MP-MC-016 | 27 Feb 2026 | ENSO regime shift: long wheat, short cornLong WEAT, short CORN for the second half of 2026 as El Niño hits Australian wheat and helps the US Corn Belt | WEAT beats CORN in the second half of 2026; Niño 3.4 above 0.5 degrees as the weather checkMeasured on: WEAT against CORN | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the El Niño we expected has arrived and is strong, but the trade has not paid yet: wheat (WEAT) and corn (CORN) are both slightly lower since our call on 27 February and corn has done better since end June. Our window for the second half of 2026 is still open. |
| MP-MC-015 | 24 Feb 2026 | Industrials over software (Siemens Energy)A durable rotation from software to physical infrastructure: overweight Siemens Energy (base target 170 to 180 euros, bull 200 plus), pair long Siemens Energy against AI software | Siemens Energy at 170 to 180 euros (bull above 200); no horizon or triggerMeasured on: Siemens Energy (ENR.DE); GE Vernova; S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 Siemens Energy is at 126.92 euros, down 24 percent since our call while the S&P 500 rose 10 percent. It closed above our 170 to 180 euro base target in May but fell back. Its orders and US factory data stayed strong, but on price the call is looking wrong. |
| MP-MC-014 | 18 Feb 2026 | US housing thaw (INVH, HD)Position for the thaw: accumulate Invitation Homes below $27 (bull $33 to 35 if mortgage rates dip below 5.5 percent) and Home Depot (base target $410 to 425) | Mortgage rates below 5.5 percent and INVH at $33 to 35; bear case $18 to 22; no horizonMeasured on: INVH and HD; 30-year mortgage rate (Freddie Mac) | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the thaw we positioned for has not come: 30-year mortgage rates are above 7 percent, not below 5.5 percent. Invitation Homes is 1 percent lower since our call at $26.56, short of our $33 to $35 bull case, and Home Depot is down 14 percent. |
| MP-MC-013 | 13 Feb 2026 | Japan broadening: unhedged and small caps over hedged exportersOverweight SCJ and unhedged EWJ, add Japanese banks, avoid hedged DXJ as yen strength drives domestic growth in 2026 | Unhedged and small cap Japan beat hedged DXJ in 2026 on a stronger yen; stop loss at minus 10 percentMeasured on: EWJ and SCJ against DXJ; USD/JPY | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the unhedged Japan fund we preferred (EWJ) is down 1 percent since our call and trails the hedged exporter fund we said to avoid (DXJ, up 5 percent), and the yen has weakened since mid-February rather than strengthened. Our 2026 window is still open. |
| MP-MC-012 | 10 Feb 2026 | Autos: hybrids, power and copper over EV start-upsAnchor in Toyota and Honda, add Vistra and Constellation, hedge with Freeport and BHP, avoid capital-starved EV start-ups such as Rivian | No target, horizon or trigger; 2026 framingMeasured on: Equal-weight TM, HMC, VST, CEG, FCX and BHP against the S&P 500 and RIVN | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the six names we favoured are down 3 percent as a group since our call while the S&P 500 rose 9 percent, though they are well ahead of Rivian, the kind of start-up we said to avoid, which fell 19 percent. With no horizon set, we keep watching. |
| MP-MC-011 | 4 Feb 2026 | China tech: the compressed spring (KWEB)Chinese tech at a 50 percent discount is the mispricing; KWEB base case $38 to 45, bear $30 to 33, 18 to 24 month horizon, 20 to 30 percent drawdown tolerance | KWEB to $38 to 45; bear case $30 to 33; drawdown tolerance 20 to 30 percent; 18 to 24 monthsMeasured on: KWEB | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 KWEB is at $22.74, down 32 percent since our call and well under our $30 to 33 bear case, beyond the 20 to 30 percent drawdown we said to tolerate, so we close this China tech call as wrong. |
| MP-MC-010 | 30 Jan 2026 | German banks: long Deutsche Bank, short CommerzbankLong Deutsche Bank with a 38 to 42 euro 12-month target; consider long Deutsche Bank against short Commerzbank | Deutsche Bank at 38 to 42 euros by 30 Jan 2027Measured on: DBK.DE and CBK.DE | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 Deutsche Bank is at 30.08 euros, down 10 percent since our call and short of our 38 to 42 euro target, while Commerzbank, the suggested short leg, is up 9 percent, so this call is looking wrong with three months of its window left. |
| MP-MC-009 | 27 Jan 2026 | Small caps: 2026 as the year of the Russell 2000Small caps outperform in 2026; Russell 2000 technical targets 2,800 and 3,000; favour quality over passive IWM | Russell 2000 beats the S&P 500 in 2026; levels 2,800 and 3,000; no trigger statedMeasured on: Russell 2000 (^RUT) against the S&P 500 | Too early As of 30 October 2026 the Russell 2000 is at 2,812, above our 2,800 projection but back below the 3,000 target it passed in June, and since our call it is up 5 percent against 9 percent for the S&P 500. With two months of 2026 left we are still watching. |
| MP-MC-008 | 24 Jan 2026 | European defence over US defenceThe Great Divergence: long European defence against US defence this year; Rheinmetall overvalued against a 718 euro fair value | European defence beats US defence in 2026; no trigger statedMeasured on: EUAD (European aerospace and defence ETF) against ITA; Rheinmetall | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 European defence has lagged US defence since our call, with the EUAD fund down 16 percent against 11 percent for ITA, so our Great Divergence call is looking wrong, although our warning that Rheinmetall was overvalued has played out: it is down 43 percent. |
| MP-MC-007 | 17 Jan 2026 | Lululemon over Nike turnaroundNike is the moat, Lululemon is the trade: tilt to LULU for 12 to 18 months, base $200 to 240, bear $160, new CEO by March 2026 | CEO named by March 2026 and a re-rating; LULU bear case $160; 12 to 18 month horizonMeasured on: LULU (NKE for context) | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 Lululemon is at $107, down 47 percent since our call and a third below our $160 bear case, after the new chief executive was named later than our March timetable and no re-rating followed, so we close this call as wrong. |
| MP-MC-006 | 16 Jan 2026 | Fintech super-app barbell (COIN, SCHW, HOOD)Barbell of Coinbase (strategic hold), Schwab (value) and Robinhood (growth) in the 2026 race to the financial super-app middle | Robinhood invalidates on falling MAUs or a prediction market ban; Schwab on a stalled Forge integration or delayed crypto launch; 2026 framingMeasured on: Equal-weight COIN, SCHW and HOOD against the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 our fintech barbell of Coinbase, Schwab and Robinhood is down about 26 percent since our call while the S&P 500 is up 9 percent; Robinhood's stated tripwires have not fired, but the call is looking wrong. |
| MP-MC-005 | 11 Jan 2026 | Venezuela gambit: oil services, refiner and the oil SlogThe trade is the fixers, not oil: SLB and HAL for 3 to 6 months (target up 20 to 30 percent, stop down 15 percent), VLO for 1 to 3 years, Brent base case $50 to 60 | SLB and HAL up 20 to 30 percent within 3 to 6 months without hitting a 15 percent stop; Brent at $50 to 60Measured on: SLB, HAL and VLO; Brent futures (BZ=F) | Wrong As of 30 October 2026 we mark this call wrong: SLB and Halliburton touched our 20 to 30 percent target in the spring but ended our six month window only 5 to 6 percent higher, and Brent is far above our $50 to 60 base case. Valero, our longer hold, has more than doubled. |
| MP-MC-004 | 10 Jan 2026 | Timeshares re-rating (VAC, HGV, TNL)Build a small basket of Marriott Vacations, Hilton Grand Vacations and Travel + Leisure for a multiple re-rating over 2026 to mid-2027 | Basket re-rates within the 2026 to mid-2027 window; no price targetMeasured on: Equal-weight VAC, HGV and TNL against the S&P 500 | Leaning right As of 30 October 2026 our timeshare basket is up about 17 percent since early January against 9 percent for the S&P 500, but nearly all of it is Marriott Vacations; Hilton Grand Vacations is down 20 percent and cut its guidance in October, and Travel + Leisure is down 4 percent. |
| MP-MC-003 | 10 Jan 2026 | Brazil 2.0: Selic easing and EWZBrazil is a structural opportunity misread as a political quagmire; Selic to 11 to 12 percent by end 2026, with EWZ as the vehicle | Selic at 11 to 12 percent by year end 2026; thesis breaks if inflation stays above 5 percent with a 15 percent SelicMeasured on: Selic rate; EWZ against the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 Brazil's central bank has cut to 13.75 percent, not the 11 to 12 percent we expected by year end, and EWZ is down 2 percent since our call against a 9 percent S&P 500 gain, so the call is looking wrong, although our inflation trigger has not fired. |
| MP-MC-002 | 4 Jan 2026 | AI cycle: adopters over chip buildersCut chip builders (SMH) and rotate into software platforms (IGV) and Phase 4 adopters (JPM, WMT, UPS, JBHT); 2026 returns belong to adopters | IGV and the adopters beat SMH in 2026, thesis through 2027; no trigger statedMeasured on: SMH against IGV; named adopters against the S&P 500 | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the chip ETF we expected to lag, SMH, is up 40 percent since 2 January, while IGV, the software ETF we favoured, is up 2 percent and our named adopters trail the S&P 500, so this rotation call is looking wrong with two months of 2026 left. |
| MP-MC-001 | 4 Jan 2026 | SpaceX IPO and orbital AI infrastructureSpaceX is an AI infrastructure bid, not a transport story; base case (60 percent probability) a 2026 IPO raising $30 to 35 billion at $1.2 to 1.5 trillion | A 2026 listing raising $30 to 35 billion at a $1.2 to 1.5 trillion valuation; no invalidation trigger statedMeasured on: SpaceX IPO terms (priced 11 Jun 2026); SPCX shares | Too early As of 30 October 2026 SpaceX has listed, in June as our base case expected, but it raised $75 billion at $1.77 trillion after absorbing xAI, well outside our $30 to 35 billion and $1.2 to 1.5 trillion ranges. The shares are back at the $135 offer price, 16 percent below their first close. |
Most Learn articles explain what to watch rather than make a call. These six stated a test.
| ID | Published | Article · our call | Reference | What would prove us wrong | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MP-LC-006 | 25 Sep 2026 | The five-year auction, measured against every one since 2008The weak September sale showed weak demand for this maturity | Bid to cover 2.21 at the 23 September saleHorizon: The next five year sale, late October | Bid to cover above 2.35 at the next sale (a weak session only); below 2.25 would confirm | Inconclusive The next five year sale, on 27 October 2026, was covered 2.33 times, between our two lines of 2.25 and 2.35, so the test settled nothing either way. |
| MP-LC-005 | 16 Sep 2026 | The pipeline is the obvious problem, but the actual limitation is at the refineryThe binding constraint is refining capacity, not the pipeline | Refineries running near maximum, on our research in mid SeptemberHorizon: Not stated | US refinery use falls below 95 percent while the diesel price gap stays large | Wrong US refinery use fell below our 95 percent line within days, to 94.0 percent in the week to 18 September, and ran at about 92.8 percent in October while diesel stayed tight. Our test did not allow for maintenance. |
| MP-LC-004 | 10 Sep 2026 | Over the past ten weeks software has beaten semiconductorsThe summer lag in chips was a short setback | SOXX 568.64 and IGV 106.48 (30 September closes, the start of the test)Horizon: Fourth quarter 2026 | Chips fall behind software again in the fourth quarter, measured from the end of September | Leaning wrong As of 30 October 2026 the chip fund SOXX is down 17.1 percent since 30 September, against 2.1 percent for the software fund IGV. The test ends on 31 December. |
| MP-LC-003 | 3 Sep 2026 | The promise that tripled in nine monthsThe AI build keeps escalating: combined free cash flow turns negative in the September quarter and unstarted leases keep rising | Unstarted leases 830.5 billion dollars at 30 June (our sum)Horizon: Third quarter filings | Combined free cash flow positive in the September quarter, or unstarted leases falling or growing by less than 50 billion dollars | Resolved on 30 October 2026: combined free cash flow was negative in the third quarter on our sum, and unstarted leases rose 185.2 billion dollars. Also scored in our Daily Compass tests. |
| MP-LC-002 | 16 Aug 2026 | Weekly Brief: The illusion of coolingThe July cooling in inflation was an illusion | Brent 88.52 dollars and 30 year yield 5.265 percent (14 August closes)Horizon: Not stated | Brent below 83.55 dollars and the 30 year yield below 5.19 percent | Our kill test needed both legs: the 30 year yield dipped to 5.174 percent on 25 August, but Brent never closed below 87.84 dollars after we wrote. Inflation rose to 3.7 percent in September. |
| MP-LC-001 | 31 Jul 2026 | The barrels that cannot legally be soldOil averages above 100 dollars a barrel in 2027, against an official forecast of 65 | Front month Brent 90.12 dollars (31 July close)Horizon: 2027 average | Brent below 80 dollars with the futures curve in contango; tanker transits above 100 a day; oil volatility below 45; or two soft inflation prints in a row | Wrong Oil volatility closed below 45 on 28 August, one of the conditions we said would prove us wrong, and we did not say so then. Brent has since risen to 117.64 dollars, but we keep to our wording. |
We score Buy, Sell, Reduce and Avoid calls and dated tests. Hold and watchlist views are listed but not scored. A call is right when its own test is met or the price reaches our fair value, and wrong when its stated trigger fires, its window closes without the test being met or the price moves beyond the far end of our own range. Until then it stays open, marked as leaning right, leaning wrong or too early. We grade on the closing price of the review date, never on the best day, and closed results are not reopened. Daily Compass results from 9 June to 11 August come from the daily scorecard we kept at the time; from 12 August every test is listed one by one.
1 · We save the original view
The research, its publication date and the price that day are recorded when we publish.
2 · We say what would prove it wrong
Each call gets a test, a fair value or a range before anyone knows the outcome.
3 · We grade on the review date
We use the closing price on the review date, never the best day. Open calls count neither way.
4 · We publish the result
Right and wrong calls stay visible, each with a dated note on what happened.
Judge the research by the full record.
Explore what we got right, what we got wrong and what is still developing, then try the complete research process free for 7 days.